Home Heart + Soul Outgoing or shy? It's Meat vs. Plants

Outgoing or shy? It's Meat vs. Plants

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

We know there are introverts and extroverts, but could it be that what you eat influences these personality traits?  Scientists believe they have uncovered a connection between nutrition and personality—especially regarding meat intake.

In a study from the University Hospital Leipzig, body mass index (BMI) and scores of extroversion and depression were obtained from people who consumed meat and people who ate plant-based vegetarian diets.  The participants in the study who ate a plant-based diet had lower BMI but did not have any correlation to depressive symptoms.

 As the frequency of meat product consumption decreased, the individuals became less and less extroverted.  The study suggested that it may be due to the isolation and separate eating habits that vegetarians face in a society where eating meat is still prevalent.  Higher BMI was related to consuming meat products more frequently.    

 The effects of nutrition on personality have been studied in many different ways before.  In an eye-opening study from 2013, the nutrition of adolescents and their personality traits were studied–but with the right education about healthier choices, personality traits could be altered.  This suggests a malleability of personality and nutrition, instead of a concrete establishment of personality from childhood eating patterns.

 In this previous study, after education about proper nutrition, the adolescents experienced an increase in stability, sociability, and responsibility while impulsive behaviors decreased.  This was accomplished by reducing processed meat and meat products, breads, frozen foods, sugary drinks, and noodles. 

Of the two groups of study participants identified with either high or low stability, the group labeled with lower stability consumed more meat and processed products, breads, frozen foods, noodles, and sugary drinks; and the group with the most stability consumed the most milk and dairy products.  The group with the least amount of impulsiveness consumed the most canned foods (though it was not stated if it was meat or vegetables), and the adolescents with the most impulsive personality traits ate more meat and processed bread products.

After a proper nutritional education program, the adolescents learned healthier eating patterns and successfully reduced their blood level of sodium, while increasing their calcium, iron, zinc, magnesium, and potassium.  The rapid changes in their nutrient profiles reflect how easily personality can be influenced not just by the consumption of meat alone, but the consumption of products which may leave us lacking in proper nutrients and overloaded in sodium.

References

Medawar, E.; Enzenbach, C.; Roehr, S., et al. Less Animal-Based Food, Better Weight Status: Associations of the Restriction of Animal-Based Product Intake with Body-Mass-Index, Depressive Symptoms and Personality in the General PopulationNutrients 202012, 1492.

Lee, Kyung-Ock, and Eun Ju Cho. “Comparison of Consumption of Processed Food and Personality of Middle School Students on Nutrition Education.” Journal of the Korean Society of Food Science and Nutrition, vol. 42, no. 10, 2013, pp. 1660–1607., doi:https://doi.org/10.3746/jkfn.2013.42.10.1600.

4 COMMENTS

  1. It would be helpful; if y'all listed study size along with results—how many people involved? This is the second news piece I've read on this site, neither of which mentioned study size. Therefotre—bogus?

    • Hi David,
      If an article you read here piques your interest, you are more than welcome to click on the linked study in the references section below the article to learn more about study size if it isn't mentioned. The information provided in our articles are not meant to be an extensive and exhaustive write-up but are meant to inform readers about where they can find this information for themselves, and why they might want to spend the time reading the actual source.

    • Sorry David, unless you can read Korean you're not going to find that sample size. This article was based on an abstract pulled from a Korean nutrition journal.

      • Hi Matt,

        The article was not based on an abstract in Korean. There were 2 studies referenced, both of which were in English. The one that the article was based on is in English and free full-text links available in English, which you can find by simply clicking on the reference and then clicking on the button which says “full-text links”. I would advise you to read more carefully in the future, as all the information is available to you in just 2 clicks. Please stop spreading misinformation. https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/12/5/1492/htm

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

What Intermittent Fasting Does for Your Muscles

One of the biggest health trends to shake up the nutrition and fitness world in the past...

Think Before You Zinc

Just like with eggs (popular one day with health-proven benefits and then shunned the next), zinc shares an on-again/off-again reputation for whether...

Migraines? There’s an app for that

Migraines are extremely painful headaches that can present sensitivity to light and sound.  Some migraine sufferers can have migraines “with aura” which...

Pre-surgical music reduces need for Pain-killers

The power of music has been reinforced with a recent meta-analysis study published last month. The team of physicians investigated if listening to music...